|
Flies reduce weight
gains in cattle by sucking blood and causing irritation; the
animals expend extra energy trying to get rid of them, and spend
time shaded up swatting at flies when they should be grazing.
Horn flies cause the most economic loss and often reduce daily
gain in calves 1/8 to 1/4 pound. Research at Auburn, California
showed calves from herds with fly control gained 1/2 pound more
per day than calves from unprotected herds. In Nebraska, horn
fly control resulted in 14 pounds higher weaning weight per
calf. Georgia tests (where fly season is 5 months long) showed
fly control could give as much as 40 more pounds per calf.
Back rubbers and dust
bags can be put in gateways where cattle travel every day, or
near water sources. Oral larvacides in mineral mixes or given by
bolus kill larvae after eggs are laid in manure. This is
effective for 8 to 12 weeks, unless flies come in from untreated
herds. Pour-on chemicals and sprays can reduce flies but must be
repeated regularly. Insecticide ear tags can be put in at the
start of fly season and the animal does the rest, rubbing
insectide over shoulders and body as she slings her head at
flies.
Insecticide
Resistance to Fly Tags
The first fly tags contained pyrethroids, but by mid l980’s
flies began to develop resistance to pyrethroids.
Organophosphate tags were the next step. Resistance occurs
because a small percentage of flies withstand the effect on
their nervous system or produce an enzyme that breaks down the
chemical before it can kill them. These flies survive, and
though they are a minority at first, they are soon the majority,
since they live to produce offspring--and their resistance is
passed on.
Horn flies’ life
cycle is about 11 days, with many generations per season. With
suseptible flies killed off, resistant flies soon increase
dramatically. This occurs faster in regions with a long fly
season. In northern climates it took years before resistant
flies were noticed whereas in the South resistance occurred
sooner. In mountain regions fly season is longer at lower
elevations so resistance problems occurred first in the lower
valleys.
Resistance has been
sped up by applying insecticide at low levels. Insecticide ear
tags work best with two tags per animal, one in each ear--or
four tags per cow-calf pair. Some stockman put one per animal,
and some use only one tag (in either cow or calf—only 25% of
recommended dose of insecticide). But dosage that low can cause
fly resistance. One company developed an organophosphate tag
approved for one per animal (two are still recommended for
optimum control of horn flies). Test results showed these tags
perform well at one per animal, but not for as long; fly control
with just one tag drops dramatically after 12 to 14 weeks. The
protection may run out when needed most.
Most ranchers put
two tags in either cow or calf. It’s better to put both in the
cow rather than both in the calf. The cow has more body surface;
more flies are killed and she does a better job of spreading
insecticide onto the calf than the calf can spread it to the
cow. Don’t depend on tagging just calves. Studies show that if
just the calf is tagged you get only 50% of the fly control
you’d have if tagging the cow and not the calf.
Resistance is
hastened by leaving tags in all year long. After 5 months,
insecticide level drops below what will kill flies, and
continues to drop til there is none left. In a late fall, if
flies are still active after tags lose effectiveness, low levels
lead to fly resistence. It’s wise to remove tags in the fall.
Use of the same type of insecticide for many years will result
in fly resistance, no matter how well managed your program. You
must rotate between synthetic pyrethroids and organophosphates.
In southern regions with long fly seasons, this alternation
should be done yearly or even more often. In northern areas, the
same class of tag can be used 2 or 3 years before switching--to
allow time for resistance to one type to disappear from the main
fly population before that type of tag is used again.
If you’ve used
organophosphate tags for 2 or 3 years, you can switch back to
pyrethroid; second or third-generation pyrethroids may work as
well as early ones did. Most veterinarians recommend
organophosphate tags for 2 years, then pyrethroids for 1 year,
then back to organophosphates. Flies develop resistance more
slowly to organophosphates. Because of shorter fly season in the
North and Midwest (15-18 generations per season compared to
20-25 or more in the South), Midwest and northern producers
often rotate yearly between organophosphates and the cheaper
pyrethroid tags, but the newer, more potent third-generation
pyrethroids are recommended and are not as cheap as the older
type. Rotating among pyrethroids won’t give adequate control; if
flies are resistant to one they are resistant to the others. The
same goes for organophosphates. You have to switch classes
completely when you change to a different type of tag. Many vets
don’t recommend the new tags that contain both classes;
eventually flies will develop resistance and then you’ll have
nothing to switch to.
To know if tags are
working, observe the number of horn flies on the backs and
shoulders of your cows. If you recently tagged them and still
see large numbers of flies, you have a large population of
resistant flies.
When to Tag
Don’t tag too early. Cattle can tolerate low fly populations in
early spring. Reserve your most effective weapon for when large
numbers take a toll on unprotected cattle. Tags should be
installed when there are 50 to 100 flies on each animal. Some
tags are effective up to 5 months; if you can wait til May or
later to put them in, the better your season-long control will
be.
The most important time to control flies is during lactation,
for most economic advantage—it can make a difference in weaning
weights. If you wean in Fall, install tags in early June. Use
pour-ons or dust applicators earlier than that if needed. If you
wean in mid-summer, fly tag the cows earlier.
Tags are most effective the first 60 days; tagging in July gives
excellent control through the peak of the fly season. If you tag
in May before cattle go to pasture you can use a different
insecticide as a pour-on, dust bag or oiler, starting early
August (this may not be feasible if cattle are on summer range).
Using a different insecticide late in the fly season will kill
any that are becoming resistant to the tags, and will kill any
buildup of flies due to waning of the tags’ effectiveness. This
reduces the number of resistant flies going into overwintering
phase, making fly control easier next year.
Feed-Through Fly
Control
Several products are marketed as feed-through larvicides, put
into the mineral/salt mix or feed. Since most cattle are on
pasture during fly season, more cattlemen use these in a mineral
mix rather than feed. When cattle consume the product it goes
through the digestive tract and ends up in the manure. Horn
flies lay their eggs in fresh cattle manure, and when the eggs
hatch, the immature larval stages are hindered by the active
ingredients in the feed-through product.
Dr. Jack Lloyd,
University of Wyoming, says there are a couple ingredients that
can be used in these products. “The one Moormans use in their
mineral mix is methoprene, which is an insect growth regulator.
It’s not a widely used approach to fly control, but it works if
your cattle are isolated and not near other herds. The
methoprene mimics a juvenile hormone in the insect, making it
stay in the larval stage longer than would be healthy for it,”
he says. They can’t live forever in the juvenile stage and
eventually die.
Fly resistance has
become a problem with ear tags because so many stockmen use
them, but Lloyd does not envision this ever becoming a big
problem with feed-through products. “Theoretically it could
happen because insects are very resourceful and at some point in
time they could become resistant; there could be some changes in
the insect that would make it less susceptible. But I don’t
think there is enough of this product in use right now to put
that kind of pressure on the fly population--to create
resistance.”
A bigger problem
with using a feed-through is that you need to be in an isolated
area. Otherwise flies will migrate to your herd from surrounding
areas. “When we were doing research using boluses containing an
insect growth regulator, which is the same sort of approach but
affecting the cuticle of the insect so it can’t go from one
stage to the next and dies in the molting process, we still
didn’t see significant fly reduction in our trial, even though
we knew every animal was treated,” says Lloyd. The reason for
that was the fact there were plenty of cattle near enough to
provide migrating flies into their test herd.
About 10 percent of
flies found on your cattle are coming in from other areas, at
any given time. So you really need to have an isolated herd
where there are no other flies coming in, for a feed- through
product to work very well.
Another problem
with reliance on this type of product in a mineral mix or salt
block is variability of consumption. Some times of year, and on
some pastures or feeds, cattle eat more salt or less. And some
individuals will always consume more while others eat very
little, or none. With this kind of variability, the
effectiveness of the feed-through control is also variable.
Natural Ways to
Reduce Horn Flies
In recent years some stockmen have been looking at ways to
control flies without resorting to chemicals. One method is use
of diatomaceous earth (silica powder from sedimentary rock which
contains the remains of ancient one-celled plants deposited at
the bottom of old sea beds in what is now part of the western
U.S.), mixing it in livestock feed. Much of it passes on through
with manure, where it inhibits fly larvae. The theory is that
this powder is microscopically sharp—not enough to hurt the
animal internally, but enough to possibly scratch the protective
coating on fly larvae as they move around in the manure. The
drawback to relying upon this method is that it has not been
scientifically proven to work very well.
Another way to
break the flies’ life cycle is with predator wasps. These tiny
nocturnal wasps are harmless to humans and animals and spend
their entire lives on or near manure. The females search through
manure and lay eggs in the pupae of house flies, stable flies
and a number of other flies. The wasp eggs hatch quickly and use
dormant fly pupae as food, killing the fly before it can
develop.
These wasps are
generally present wherever there are flies, but not in large
enough numbers to control their population. You can purchase
more wasps, however, and if you release them early in the fly
season and put out more periodically through summer, you may be
able to reduce fly numbers.
In large pasture
areas this is not very practical, but around barns, corrals,
feedlots, and other confinement areas, it may help. Suppliers of
fly parasite wasps recommend spreading them on the manure in
corrals, early in the spring before flies are numerous, and
putting out more wasps every 30 days. The number of wasps needed
depends on the number of animals on the premises. If you use
biological fly control, however, you must not use insecticides
or they will kill the wasp population along with the flies.
Another natural way
to control flies (and more effective for horn flies) is dung
beetles. These beetles spend their lives in manure and the
adults use the liquid contents for nourishment. They lay their
eggs in manure and some types bury the eggs in balls of manure.
Bill Clymer, PhD (parasitologist in Amarillo, Texas) says dung
beetles are our best allies for controlling parasites that
depend on manure for their life cycle.
“In Australia they
are used for horn fly control. Studies show that these beetles
bury 95 percent of the horn flies and 90 percent of the eggs
from internal parasites,” says Clymer. The beetles’
activity—tunneling and burying—disrupts the life cycle; even if
the eggs hatch they can’t get back up to ground surface.
“Several years ago
I was doing horn fly research in south Texas with ear tags. A
flight of dung beetles moved in and we had to do the study over
again because my control group (that had no insecticide tags)
all went to zero. The dung beetles completely eliminated horn
flies in the manure,” says Clymer. A good population of dung
beetles can effectively control them. Several types of beetles
were imported in the 1970’s and 80’s into North America and
Australia. Our native species are good, but not quite as
effective as those from Africa, according to Clymer.
Long term control of flies is better achieved with beetles than
with sporadic application of toxic chemicals. Fly resistance to
chemical weapons (such as insecticide ear tags) becomes a
problem when relying upon chemicals alone. Mechanical
destruction of the manure pat by beetles is more dependable.
But if you are
going to use natural methods of fly control like dung beetles or
parasite wasps, you must be careful when using insecticides or
you will destroy the wasps or beetles. And some types of
dewormers/pesticides (such as ivermectin) will eventually
decimate dung beetle populations because they are lethal to the
larval stages of the beetles. When selecting a fly control
method, it pays to learn all you can about how to make it most
effective, and if you opt for natural control you need to make
sure you are not inadvertantly defeating your goal by use of
certain chemicals or other types of pesticides.
Face Flies
In earlier years it was thought that face flies had sponging
mouth parts similar to those of the common house fly, but in
1993 Kansas State University researchers discovered (with use of
an electron microscope) that the face fly has very sharp
microscopic teeth. Located on the end of the fly’s tongue, these
teeth are used to irritate the eye, making it water. This gives
the fly access to the mainstay of its diet—the protein-rich eye
secretions. Then the pinkeye bacteria more readily gain access
to the eye, via the tiny wounds in the cornea caused by the
bites of the face fly. The scrapes reduce some of the eye’s
protective defenses. Also, if flies scrape an infected eye and
then move to another animal, they transmit the bacteria to the
next animal. |